Selective Root Retreatment of an endodontic failure
Selective root retreatment is an endodontic retreatment procedure of a failing root canal. The difference is that in selective retreatment we only treat the root(s) that shows evidence of failure.
When is it advisable to do selective root retreatment?
Typically this will be a tooth with a root canal where only one root has evidence of failing, usually a radiolucent apical lesion. Most commonly we see this when there is anatomy that the original doctor did not clean out. Therefore, an upper MB2 canal is the most likely scenario but any multi-rooted tooth can have this.
Why do many dentists avoid doing selective retreatment?
Number one is there is not a lot known about this technique. The fact there is not a lot known about the technique means few dentists even know that this is possible. Secondly there is a stigma against it in the same way and for the same reasons as to why dentists shy away from things like the Hall technique. Dentists and humans in general have a general misconception that if we put in more work the results will naturally improve. So because things like the Hall technique and selective root retreatment are easier, they must be inferior. However, this is not necessarily the case and we should rely on the research to guide our clinical decisions.
Another reason that few do this is the procedure is do to the relationship business of endodontics. Retreats of all kinds are mostly going to be done by specialists for general dentists. A specialist may just retreat the whole tooth because they do not want their referral source thinking they are lazy or trying to take a short cut. Basically the extra time it takes to clean out the other roots is less time and risk than explaining the rational to their referrals.
Research on selective root retreatment
There is not a lot of research on this technique. This is do to the fact that selective retreatment is seen as taking a short cut and few have the courage to take a stand and say this works. Again we should let the evidence decide what we do. Nudra JOE 2015 is one of the best articles on the technique.